Improper Charges at Sentencing

I recall at a sentencing some years ago, proposing to a judge that the State of Florida was not entitled to recover Investigative Costs for no costs had been established at trial and no discovery had been presented pre-trial through discovery to assert that the State was entitled to them. The response was: “Show me a case. . . show me a case!” Well, it just seemed axiomatic that if it were not proven, it cannot be simply assumed. Nonetheless, I let it go. Later, however, I came upon this simple case. A doctrine I had seen more than once. Yes, I had been right all along. The case was, Clase v. State, 361 So. 3d 881, 881 (4 DCA 2023). Therein the court declared:
“The court reversed a $50 investigative-cost assessment because the State failed to present competent substantial evidence establishing the amount requested, while permitting the costs to be reimposed on remand if adequately supported.” (Clase, head-point ruling at 881.)
This made me wonder how many untold amounts of money sit on the books which have been paid over the years into a system wherein costs are covered for almost every conceivable charge, to wit: money to criminal trust funds; surcharges; clerks fees; crimes compensations funds, etc. Little if any of these charges existed in my early years and the sums have grown exponentially. Some of which remain unpaid can result in reincarceration. Others are imposed as liens.
I simply feel caution should be made by the State Attorney’s Office in the demand for proof and a micro-analysis at sentencing of what has or has not happened to support the sentence. Keep in mind, average costs for simply a small misdemeanor conviction may be as high as $1,400 dollars; felonies twice as high. Then add to those costs of probation and the daily charges of incarceration of $50.00 per day, often these individuals never are free of the financial destruction that a system generates. Likewise, you must keep in mind, not all people that enter a plea are guilty but instead enter the plea to avoid a trial. Look at one incidence, a defendant housed in the county jail is charged $50.00 per day for incarceration. What’s that per year? A sum upon departure of $18,250. Do you truly believe that that individual will later own a home with that lien imposed on his or her record? Mighty difficult.



Comments