top of page

JUDICIAL NEUTRALITY

Writer: Jeffrey Wiggs
Jeffrey Wiggs
Nov 4
9 min read

In the past and on more than one occasion, individuals have appeared within my office frustrated those that occupy the bench. Frequently, they were represented by the Office of the Public Defender. They had appeared in court and had some taste of the disposition of the court. Way too often, they assumed for whatever reason that the disposition of the court might lend itself to simply “firing” a judge. Kind of like sending a milk shake back that just was a little too sour.  It's not so simple.  We are not at liberty to discharge a judge, and much protection is afforded them.  The law does assume their fairness, and today, in some states such protection should possibly question whether stronger safeguards should be reevaluated. However, Florida provides a large level of security to the bench and for good reason. We are not at liberty to easily discharge a judge.  


Florida law requires a judge’s disqualification when the judge’s impartiality might reasonably and quite logically be questioned, including for personal bias, specified prior involvement, certain economic interests, relationships, or participation that compromises judicial neutrality Livingston v. State, 441 So. 2d 1083, 1086 (1983), Inquiry Concerning a Judge (frank), 753 So. 2d 1228, 1239 (2000). That’s a pretty broad statement to say; such facts clearly indicate an inability that we can assume he or she might not be fair.


Judicial Neutrality


The disqualification inquiry focuses on circumstances from which a litigant may reasonably question the judge’s impartiality, rather than the judge’s own perception of an ability to remain fair Livingston v. State, 441 So. 2d 1083, 1086 (1983). Litigants way too often simply just don’t like the disposition of a judge.  In family law they might have heard that the judge always rules in favor of the wife or wants to appear tough on criminals in a criminal case.  Neutrality and disposition do not concern itself with the inner character of the judge and any frailties, but those that might certainly and reasonably impact “this” particular individual based on “specific” known facts. 


A judge has an unequivocal obligation to act in a manner promoting public confidence in the judiciary’s integrity and impartiality Inquiry Concerning a Judge (Maxwell), 994 So. 2d 974, 978 (2008). Judicial conduct must avoid impropriety and its appearance, and a judge may not allow personal relationships to influence judicial conduct or judgment Merckle v. State, 529 So. 2d 269, 272 (1988).


A court may question witnesses when necessary in the interests of justice, including to ascertain the truth or clarify an issue, but may not use questions or comments to supply essential elements of the State’s case R.O. v. State, 46 So. 3d 124, 126 (2010). A judge’s words and actions should not lean toward either the prosecution or defense, and judicial neutrality is impaired when the judge becomes a participant or advocate R.O. v. State, 46 So. 3d 124, 126 (2010). While ruling may suggest that fact, such events will make it difficult to enable a party to recuse a judge if the rulings are supported by any foundation within the law.


In R.O. v. State, 46 So. 3d 124, 126 (2010), the court held that the trial judge departed from the appearance of neutrality and became an active participant and advocate specifically because the judge actively sought out and questioned whether the accused had cocaine R.O. v. State, 46 So. 3d 124, 126 (2010). 


Bias and Reasonable Questions About Impartiality


A party seeking disqualification based on alleged partiality need show a well-grounded fear that the party will not receive a fair trial; the focus is the feeling reasonably arising in the litigant’s mind and the basis for it, not the judge’s personal assessment Livingston v. State, 441 So. 2d 1083, 1086 (1983).


Canon 3E, as reproduced in Inquiry Concerning a Judge (frank), 753 So. 2d 1228, 1239 (2000), directs disqualification when impartiality might reasonably be questioned, including when the judge has a personal bias or prejudice concerning a party or the party’s lawyer, or personal knowledge of disputed evidentiary facts Inquiry Concerning a Judge (frank), 753 So. 2d 1228, 1239 (2000).


A judge should disclose on the record information that the judge believes parties or counsel might consider relevant to disqualification, even when the judge believes no genuine basis for disqualification exists Becker v. Becker, 279 So. 3d 813, 815 (2019). In Becker v. Becker, 279 So. 3d 813, 815 (2019), the court held that the trial judge should disclose the prior representation at the first practicable opportunity specifically because an attorney in the contested marital-dissolution case had personally represented that judge in the judge’s own dissolution proceeding, even though the representation had ended years earlier and the judge believed no bias existed Becker v. Becker, 279 So. 3d 813, 815 (2019).


Conflicts Based on Prior Involvement or Economic Interests


Canon 3E identifies potential conflicts where the judge previously served as a lawyer or lower-court judge in the matter, where a lawyer formerly associated with the judge worked on the matter during that association, or where the judge was a material witness concerning the matter Inquiry Concerning a Judge (frank), 753 So. 2d 1228, 1239 (2000).


Canon 3E also identifies conflicts where the judge knows that the judge, individually or as a fiduciary, or the judge’s spouse, parent, child, or another family member residing in the judge’s household has an economic interest in the subject matter or a party, or another more-than-de-minimis interest that could be substantially affected by the proceeding Inquiry Concerning a Judge (frank), 753 So. 2d 1228, 1239 (2000).


Under Fla. Stat. § 38.02, a party—or a person or corporation interested in the litigation’s subject matter—may suggest disqualification when the judge or a person related to the judge within the third degree is a party or interested in the result, when the judge is related within the third degree to counsel of record, or when the judge is a material witness for or against a party Fla. Stat. § 38.02.


Florida judges must file specified public financial reports and, by July 1 each year, a confidential verified list with the Judicial Qualifications Commission identifying corporations and other business entities in which they held a financial interest as of December 31 of the preceding year Fla. Code of Judicial Conduct Canon 6. During or after a case, a party may request whether the most recent confidential list filed by a judge contains a named person or entity that is a party or has a substantial direct or indirect financial interest in the outcome Fla. Code of Judicial Conduct Canon 6.


What Are Some Grounds


The court held that the trial judge departed from the appearance of neutrality and became an active participant and advocate specifically because the judge actively sought out and questioned whether the accused had cocaine R.O. v. State, 46 So. 3d 124, 126 (2010). When a judge becomes an active participant in the litigation seeking facts out in favor of one party of the litigation, it can be said the judge has exceeded his authority.


Asbury v. State, 765 So. 2d 965, 966 (2000) — A trial judge departs from necessary neutrality by sua sponte seeking evidence that the State did not offer; judicial neutrality is further impaired when the judge actively seeks additional evidence Asbury v. State, 765 So. 2d 965, 966 (2000). In Asbury v. State, 765 So. 2d 965, 966 (2000), the court held that the defendant was denied a fair hearing before an impartial tribunal specifically because the judge prompted the State to present evidence, sua sponte recalled witnesses, and questioned them; the court reversed and remanded Asbury v. State, 765 So. 2d 965, 966 (2000).


Inquiry Concerning a Judge (Sloop), 946 So. 2d 1046, 1055 (2006) — The Florida Supreme Court recognized its constitutional authority to remove a judge for willful or persistent failure to perform judicial duties or other conduct unbecoming a judicial officer that demonstrates present unfitness; malafides, scienter, or moral turpitude is unnecessary when the conduct demonstrates present unfitness Inquiry Concerning a Judge (Sloop), 946 So. 2d 1046, 1055 (2006).


Inquiry Concerning a Judge (mcallister), 646 So. 2d 173 (1994) — The Florida Judicial Qualifications Commission recommended discipline and removal based on conduct demonstrating unfitness for judicial office, including improper ex parte communications, abusive conduct toward criminal-defense attorneys reflecting a lack of impartiality, sexual harassment of a judicial assistant, and maintenance of an abusive and hostile work environment Inquiry Concerning a Judge (mcallister), 646 So. 2d 173 (1994). The supplied authority states the Commission’s recommendation but does not state the Florida Supreme Court’s ultimate disposition Inquiry Concerning a Judge (mcallister), 646 So. 2d 173 (1994) 


Disqualification Procedure


For disqualification based on fear of judicial prejudice, Fla. Stat. § 38.10 requires an affidavit stating the facts and reasons supporting the belief that bias or prejudice exists, accompanied by counsel of record’s certificate that the affidavit and application are made in good faith Fla. Stat. § 38.10. Upon that filing, the judge must proceed no further, and another judge must be designated as prescribed by Florida law Fla. Stat. § 38.10.


Florida case law describes three basic procedural safeguards for disqualification: a verified statement of specific facts indicating bias or prejudice, a timely application, and review by the challenged judge limited to the motion’s legal sufficiency rather than the truth of its allegations Cardinal v. Wendy's of South Florida, Inc., 529 So. 2d 335, 339 (1988).


For the conflict grounds governed by Fla. Stat. § 38.02, the suggestion must be filed within 30 days after the filing party or any attorney of record learns of the disqualification; otherwise, those grounds are treated as waived Fla. Stat. § 38.02. It also must be filed before final judgment in an action at law or before final decree in chancery Fla. Stat. § 38.02. 


If the truth of a Fla. Stat. § 38.02 suggestion appears from the record, the judge must promptly enter an order stating the filing and grounds and declaring disqualification Fla. Stat. § 38.02. If the truth does not appear from the record, the judge may require affidavits addressing the suggestion’s truth or falsity and must enter an order declaring either disqualification if true or qualification if false Fla. Stat. § 38.02. An order declaring disqualification is not reviewable or subject to collateral attack, while an order declaring qualification is not subject to collateral attack but may be reviewed by the appellate court having jurisdiction over the cause Fla. Stat. § 38.02.


After one judge has admitted disqualification and a replacement has been assigned, Fla. Stat. § 38.10 provides that the replacement judge is not disqualified merely because of alleged prejudice against the party who made the first suggestion or in favor of the adverse party, unless the replacement judge admits and holds that the judge is not fair and impartial Fla. Stat. § 38.10. If the replacement judge rules that the judge remains fair and impartial, the ruling must be entered in the court minutes, the judge proceeds with the case, and the ruling may be assigned as error and reviewed like other trial-court rulings Fla. Stat. § 38.10.


In summary, Florida law protects judicial neutrality through an objective reasonable-question standard, specific conflict grounds, disclosure and financial-reporting mechanisms, and formal disqualification procedures. The applicable grounds and procedural consequences depend on whether the asserted problem concerns bias, prior involvement, relationships, economic interests, witness status, or conduct that makes the judge appear to become an advocate. Disposition toward counsel can also support a removal basis.  Such claims should be made with caution and reserved for those that clearly avoid the rules we all share for a well founded system.  Keep in mind, you are not entitled to recuse a judge simply due to the fact you as a client don’t like him. His personal weakness or complexities are not going to remove him unless they clearly appear to trample on commonsense and neutrality in performing his or her functions.


Sources


Cases | Florida | Supreme Court of Florida | Oct 27, 1983

Cases | Florida | Supreme Court of Florida | Feb 17, 2000

Cases | Florida | Supreme Court of Florida | Sep 29, 2008

Cases | Florida | Supreme Court of Florida | Jun 9, 1988

Cases | Florida | Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District | Oct 20, 2010

Show more

Cases | Florida | Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District | Oct 20, 2010

Cases | Florida | Court of Appeal of Florida, Fourth District | Sep 6, 2000

Cases | Florida | Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District | Jan 16, 1990

Cases | Florida | Supreme Court of Florida | Oct 13, 1994

Cases | Florida | Supreme Court of Florida | Dec 7, 2006




Comments


bottom of page